Here's the Guardian again. Panel of tax ezperts plus investment committed to bring in extra tax that goes uncollected. Fairly unobjectionable right? Nope. They instead stick it to Rachel Reeves for not appointing the media showboaters it has on speed dial to her panel. It zeroes in on Sir Edward Troup.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfr ... f-insiders
In a distinguished career, Sir Edward has been a corporate lawyer in the City, an adviser to the Treasury and a commentator on tax affairs. In that last role, he wrote in the Financial Times in 1999 that “taxation is legalised extortion”.
He's also had very sernior government tax roles (starting under the Labour Government in 2004) for 13 years. He did say that rather striking phrase, but the whole paragraph isn't objectionable. Just "you want less avoidance, you write laws to stop it". He's not some ant-tax fundamentalist, as you might infer from that phrase.
Tax law does not codify some Platonic set of tax-raising principles. Taxation is legalised extortion and is valid only to the extent of the law. Tax avoidance is not paying less tax than you ‘should'. Tax avoidance is paying less tax than Parliament would have wanted. Avoidance is where Parliament got it wrong, or didn't foresee all possible combinations of circumstance. The problem of tax avoidance is reduced to the problem of finding an answer to the question of what parliament intended and making sure that this is complied with. I would not pretend this is a simple task. But recognising this as the issue and dealing with it equitably and constitutionally would be a significant step on the way to tackling avoidance effectively.
As ever, the implication is "anyone who works in the private sector for tax ever is corrupt, for the rest of their life". Like when somebody from there is seconded to a political party or the government. A friend of mine got seconded from a law firm to the DTI. It's possible that he was called in by Mr Big and told to sabotage the government, but he never mentioned it.
Comments left open for the (now) preferred BTL audience to take the hint and wade in.