- Wed Sep 27, 2023 5:40 pm
#53709
Just been thinking about Keir Starmer, and where he has brought the Labour Party since he won the leadership in early 2020. Labour is now poised to return to government, 18 long years since it last won an election. It’s a remarkable achievement, on any assessment. Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership had left the party, having suffered its worst defeat since 1935, requiring a larger swing than that achieved by Blair in 1997 to achieve a single seat majority, and mired in multiple instances of shocking anti-semitism. Starmer was facing a massive task on at least two different levels. He had first, urgently to transform his party from the corrupted nest of Trots and Tankies of various stripes, who had been emboldened by Corbyn’s leadership to colonise every level of its structure. These were people obsessed, among various other things, with the Israel/Palestine issue, who had been accustomed to the adoption of a hostile attitude towards the state of Israel that extended easily and porously into vehement and virulent hostility towards Jewish people generally. Which might have been acceptable in the SWP (or whichever sect they had migrated from), but was emphatically unacceptable in the mainstream Labour Party.
So Starmer simply had to transform his party, as a matter of priority. Furthermore, he had to be *seen* by the electorate to have transformed the Labour Party. To have made it once again an acceptable, natural, electable, and alternative party of government.
To his lasting credit, Starmer set about his task ruthlessly and without compunction. In retrospect, the only way to approach the task. It put the backs up of the Trot die-hards who remained, notably the Momentum Corbynist faction, but arguably, the party is rather better off without such individuals - including Corbyn himself.
This - the transformation and reform of the party, was Phase One of Starmer’s plan to get Labour back to government. It is all but complete, though still requires attention. Phase Two of the plan was about public perception. The need to change the public’s perception of what Labour was. More difficult, but crucial, and clearly contingent on the success of Phase One. There was, of course, a concomitant requirement for Labour to be an effective opposition, to expose the many shortcomings, failures, and downright incompetence of the Tories in government. It can be argued that the Tories were doing a good enough job of this themselves, but this ignores the reality that Starmer still had to do a ruthlessly effective job as leader of the opposition, which he did, and which would still have been required however poorly the Tories conducted themselves. But the public perception of the Labour Party *has* now changed. Labour is now *the* alternative government in waiting.
So, Phase One and Phase Two of the Starmer plan are now complete. Phase Three is the final phase, and quite simply consists of developing an offer or manifesto which voters will actively want to vote for. This phase is of course ongoing, and is possibly the trickiest phase to pull off. It’s Roy Jenkins’ long walk along a corridor with a highly polished floor carrying a priceless porcelain vase (yeah, that again).
Four years after the Labour Party was left teetering on the brink of electoral extinction, Starmer has now brought it back to an imminent return to government. In my view, I think that is an astonishing feat, given where we were.
I just really don’t think that Keir Starmer gets the recognition that he deserves for this.
"The opportunity to serve our country: that is all we ask.” John Smith, May 11, 1994.